Friday, April 8, 2016

Controlled versus Free Markets

Having no trade restrictions; not subject to government regulation; not subject to restriction or official control. - one of the definitions of Free in the Webster Dictionary

During the week I spend a lot of time reading to keep up with the ins and outs of the markets and the macro-economic environment.  I do so to try to assist me in planning my next move but as most macro-economic moves take time to develop I am not in a rush to change things.  It has been my contention that the United States and the world are in a predicament that will lead to severe pain so for the past five years I have been slowly implementing an investment strategy that I believe will benefit from my macro-economic outlook.  Most people do not want to hear my views as they are contrary to what the talking heads want you to believe and the results, if I am right, are painful but in this game you need to do your research and follow your findings in order to succeed.

This week I have been reviewing a number of articles associated with the idea of a free market.  When I first started trading back in the early 80's the markets gave you ample opportunity to prosper from good solid research.  Since then almost 40 years later those days are long gone.  With the advent of the massive control that the Federal Reserve and other central bankers now have over the markets the game has changed.  So the idea of a free market no longer exists.  As the rules of the game have changed the investment strategies need to align themselves with the new playing field so let's look at the playing fields.

A free market as the definition above shows is one where there is no government intervention.  Markets are left to their own devises.  They will move to the beat of the economic environment and the perceived opportunities available to the companies that operate in their various sectors.  When there are good times stock prices run higher as the outlook is solid and profits rise.  During these times more and more companies enter the space eventually stealing market share from the incumbents and hurting the bottom line of all businesses in that space.  The effect of this competition is lower prices to the consumer and expanding employment.  Eventually though when the profits are too thin the weak are weeded out, layoffs and bankruptcies become the norm.  Once these are cleared out the cycle repeats itself.  Market forces take care of the good times and the bad times.

Fast forward to today where there is a shrinking pool of large companies that control larger and larger portions of the global market.  Profits are spent not on research and development but on securing their position in the world by creating, as Warren Buffet terms, a "moat" around their business impregnable to others.  The result is higher prices to consumers and lower employment opportunities. These companies can handle the down turns but due to the lack of competition during recoveries there is little in the way of employment growth.  The only growth that is seen is profits.

In addition you have a Federal Reserve that is becoming more and more like the central planners of Russia and China.  They are not content to let the market operate in a vacuum but tinker with its very existence by lowering rates to juice returns to investors and providing cheap capital to the too big to fail companies.  The result is that the rich who benefit from these interventions get richer and the poor feel no effect of the "stimulus".  At present there is an ever wider dispersion between the wealthy and the poor and this disparity is creating massive problems for growth and political stability.

This intervention is not limited to the United States but has expanded across the globe.  In Japan the BOJ has not only issued debt but now owns around 40% of all the exchange traded funds on the Japanese stock markets.  Furthermore they are demanding new funds be made up of socially responsible companies (read companies that benefit the Japanese people) so they are not only providing capital but are controlling the intricate workings of the stock market itself.  China too has manipulated their markets more aggressively than the Federal Reserve but it is clear that they all have their arms firmly grasped around what used to be a free market.

In the volumes of historical documentation about the central planners of the world it is clear that any time a country pursues a path of central control, or control among the few, it never succeeds in the long run.  There may be some short term gains but eventually it all craters.  Russia blew apart, China is showing signs of instability and needs to open up to a freer market.  Japan is still struggling to stimulate inflation.  The issue is that the worse things get the tighter the central bankers' control over the market.  I have written much since the 2008 crisis and a lot of what was written was the question why, after the crisis was averted, did the Federal Reserve not move to the side?  Their job was done and it was now up to the markets to take over and sort the balance of the problems out themselves, freely; but they have continued to meddle and try to control the markets and their continued tinkering is creating the massive market instability that we face today.  

The result is going to be a very bad market collapse.  The issue is that this will stimulate them to try to control the market even tighter than before.  At some point congress will have to step up and remove the ridiculous powers of the Federal Reserve and restore them to their previous mantra of fighting inflation and lowering unemployment, freeing the markets from their grasp.  Until then my thought is that the global economy will continue to dribble forward on life support with longer recessions and little in the way of any economic recovery, forever.

Friday, April 1, 2016

The Obesity Index

"This is what people don't understand: obesity is a symptom of poverty.  It's not a lifestyle choice where people are just eating and not exercising.  It's because kids - and this is a problem with the school lunch right now - are getting sugar, fat, empty calories - lot's of calories - but no nutrition." - Tom Colicchio

Well the world's central bankers could learn a thing or two from the above statement however their "obesity" is in the form of debt.  A recent article published in the CFA magazine highlights that global debt has risen by $57 trillion between 2007 and 2014.  That is more than $8 trillion a year added or roughly $700 billion a month!  This puts global debt at more than 286% of global GDP.  The sad part is this number only counts the debt that has been issued and does not include what is referred to as "off balance sheet" debt.  These are debt obligations that are owed but have not yet been paid and have no formal debt associated with it.  Examples of this kind of debt would be the unfunded Social Security benefits, pension liabilities and entitlement programs.  If we were to include these obligations the number would be far greater.  Just taking the pension obligations the estimate is $50 trillion more pushing debt to global GDP over 300%.

This has not deterred the globe's central bankers from issuing more debt.  The reasoning seems to be that if the world has taken on this much debt what does it matter if we take on more?  Furthermore, without this infusion of capital in the form of debt the global economy would not be growing and we would be in a world of trouble, so the central bankers say.  But there are two main problems associated with this continued increase in the debt burden; the first is that borrowing no longer generates growth and the second is that instability is increasing.

Taking the first issue regarding the lack of growth, I do not know how much more of an example is required than the post Great Recession's anemic recovery.  As the debt level rises more and more money is spent on servicing the debt and ultimately it crowds out productivity.  Back in the 80's when debt was first added as a stimulant each unit of additional debt resulted in roughly a unit increase of productivity.  Today that marginal productivity has all but evaporated.  Adding more debt is have no impact on growth which is why no matter how much money is thrown at the problem or how low interest rates go there is no economic expansion.

The second issue is that as you pile more and more debt onto the world it results in shorter boom periods and longer periods of bust and recovery.  Defaults are becoming more and more common and people are becoming more and more angry at the establishment and the rules; just look at the mess created by the massive obligation of student loans in the United States.  This instability is feeding into politics as angry voters throw their weight behind people like Trump.

To me adding more debt to the global economy is like piling more sand onto a sand castle, eventually it will buckle under its own weight.  A reverse strategy would be far more effective and stimulating.  Imagine if the United States wrote off all of the student debt in one go.  All of that money would be spent on housing, cars, vacations and the like.  The stimulus would be huge.  Any consumer knows that removing the burden of debt brightens your whole day, the outlook is not cloudy and your are excited to buy something new.  Unfortunately the world has burdened its citizens with the yoke of debt and until this is lifted global economic growth will remain anemic.

If growth therefore is anemic (as it has been) and good paying jobs hard to find (as they are), the world's middle class will continue to shrink as people roll backwards.  In order to stave off the debt collector families are cutting expenditure (creating slow to no economic growth) and, according to the quote above this is one of the main causes of obesity.  Hence the birth of a new index, the Obesity Index.  If obesity continues to grow economic "stimulus" is not working.  Once there is true economic growth you should start to see obesity come under control.  As it is now a growing global problem it would point to continued poor economic growth and a disconnect between the policies of the central bankers of the world and the impact of their "stimulus" on the global economy.

Until such time as there is true global economic expansion, not growth based on fictitious money that is blindly thrown at banks, but real expansion based on growing consumer spending derived from wage increases and jobs, I guess the world will continue to consume the $1 Big Mac and deal with its waistline!

Friday, March 11, 2016

Tapped Out

Lisa Simpson, "What happened?"
Homer Simpson, "Difficult to say sweetie.  The town blew up, I built our house and you showed up.  All we know for sure is, I'm completely blameless."  
An excerpt from the video game Tapped Out featuring the Simpson's television show characters in which Homer has just blown the town up through his negligence at the nuclear power plant.

Reading about the EUs next attempt to stimulate by printing more money and the Federal Reserve's discussion on possibly moving to negative interest rates it seems that the central bankers of the world are rapidly becoming tapped out.

Looking at Japan it seems that they are finally reaching their breaking point as more monetary stimulus is having no impact other than to make the world start to wonder if they will ever be able to pay back their current debt.  The loss of confidence is not only affecting their currency but is also having a negative impact on their consumers and this is feeding into negative consumption reports.  China too is having limited success mainly due to the fact that large swathes of money that is being forced into the economy is ending up with deadbeat state run companies.

As I have repeatedly written about in this blog, debt does not solve a world's economic woes.  Taking on debt is at best a short term solution that should be used in cases where budgets are temporarily unbalanced or to put a stop gap under a financial crisis but it is not a long term solution.  Piling ever more debt onto an already massive pile does nothing other than sink the economy.  When that economy is large like the United States, it takes a lot of debt weight to sink it however, when it is small like Zimbabwe it does not take much.

One way that countries escape from this burden is to let their currency devalue and this creates opportunities to grow through exports however it also has the effect of creating inflation as global goods like oil become more expensive.  This inflation makes the overall debt level become more manageable assuming that the debt is based in the local currency and not in dollars.  For countries with debt based in dollars this depreciation can be the final death knell as has been witnessed in some South American economies but in developed nations currency depreciation is frequently used.

One way to depreciate a currency is to lower interest rates.  The result of this is that investors leave the country and move their money to countries where currency appreciation is expected along with higher interest rates.  So lowering your interest rate below zero should therefore do the trick however even this is not working as everyone is now playing that game at the expense of savers and investors the world around.  The idea that negative interest rates will stimulate by forcing investors to make their money work or by channeling debt to companies so that they can grow is not having any impact as companies and consumers are either already awash with debt, cannot obtain it or have no place to invest it; so adding more debt is never going to have the impact that the Federal reserve thinks it will.

So if lowering interest rates is not working and adding debt has not worked essentially the world is rapidly waking up to the fact that the central bankers of the world are tapped out.  And while the markets rallied today on the back of the US's stimulus package it is once again false hope.  Until there is some form of global inflation based on capacity constraints due to sustainable global growth as opposed to fictitious growth from monetary stimulus, these market rallies will be short lived and are a sucker bet.

Friday, March 4, 2016

Sell The Rips!

"Buy the dips and sell the rips." - Wall Street trading adage

In a bull market an old trading strategy that is often referred to in the press and on television is to "buy the dips".  This works well when stocks are trending higher as has been the case since 2009.  Each time the market takes a breather buyers step in adding to their positions and profit from the continuation of the bull market rally.

In a bear market the opposite holds true and that is "sell the rips".  That is when the market rallies you take advantage of the rally to either exit more of your long positions or put on new short or put options to take advantage of the next leg lower.  This is not for the faint of heart as most of us are wired to make money when things grow or go higher.  To bet that things will fall in price normally is beyond the scope of most amateur trader's mental capacity so most shun this trade as too risky.  Rather they let their positions lose money with everyone else.  There is comfort in knowing that you are not alone in losing value whereas taking a stand as a bear can be lonely and, if the market runs against you it takes a lot of mental strength to hold your ground.  So selling the rips sounds easy but in reality it is a scary proposition.

That said if past bear markets are anything to go on then this "bear" market is just warming up.  The reason I put "bear" in quotations is that until the market falls more than 20% from its highs it is not an official bear market.  As we have recently rallied back to 2000 on the S&P 500 we are a long way from a bear market but in studying bear market trends most bear markets last roughly 2 years and the vast majority of the bear market collapse happens in the last six months of that time frame.

So the first question is if we have entered a bear market then when did it begin?  If you look at the high back in May 2015 then we are barely beginning this downward cycle however some economists have placed the beginning of the bear market as the last time the Federal Reserve added money into the banking system.  This would take the beginning of the bear market back to November 2014.  If this is correct then the bear market is getting quite long in the tooth and that could mean that the bear claws are about to come out and rip a new hole in the market sending it tumbling lower within the next six months.  As an example the last bear market lasted 17 months and the Dow fell 7700 points, 5000 of which occurred in the last five months!

So why would we be entering a bear market?  There are numerous numbers to look at but I will only mention the 10 most definitive reasons:

  1. At the end of bear markets stocks indices are dragged higher by a smaller and smaller number of must have stocks.  This occurred with the FANG stocks (Facebook, Amazon, Netflix and Google).
  2. Volume is far lower on days that the market goes up than when it falls.
  3. While the oil price might be a benefit to consumers, sovereign wealth funds in oil exporting countries are selling large swathes of stocks to meet obligations at home ($220 billion last year with more than double that expected this year).
  4. China has used more than $800 billion of its wealth to support its crumbling economy and more selling is expected.
  5. While China has reported economic expansion its economy may not be growing at all if you look at the dismal export numbers reported by their largest trading partners all of whom have seen their export numbers crater.
  6. Domestic equity fund outflows have exceeded the level recorded right before the 2008 sell off.
  7. Profits at S&P 500 companies declined 12.7% in 2015 the worst decline since 2008 and a further decline is expected in the first quarter of 2016.
  8. Warm weather this winter has brought forward economic activity so there will not be an uptick in GDP later in the year as has occurred in previous years.
  9. According to Warren Buffet and other leading CEOs, the economic headwinds are stronger than they have experienced in a long time and some have said EVER.
  10. The Federal Reserve will not be able to come to the market's rescue until there is a significant sell off as the numbers coming from unemployment and inflation do not warrant stimulus.
For these reasons I believe that the best option that you have right now is to sell the rips, of which we are experiencing one as the market has roared upward more than 10% from the lows.  The next sell off should take out the recent lows and at that stage we could be in to the final capitulation phase of the bear market so get ready and don't say that you haven't been warned!

Friday, February 26, 2016

Strong Enough?

"All that is gold does not glitter, Not all those who wander are lost;
The old that is strong does not wither, Deep roots are not reached by the frost." - J.R. R. Tolkien

There is a lot of debate going on at present about whether the Federal Reserve considers the United States economy strong enough to handle a second interest rate increase.  The number out today seem to indicate that the economy is more robust than was previous thought as Q4 GDP was revised up to 1.0% from 0.7%.  While this is a significant increase 1.0% is hardly robust.  Both consumer income and spending ticked higher in January pushing inflation higher than expected.  All of these data points are positive and should give teh Federal Reserve some much needed credibility for raising rates last year however are they strong enough to force their hand in increasing rates next month or even alter this year?

Were the global economy in a stronger position I would have anticipated an increase in the near future but the issue is that the United States is rapidly becoming the only shining star providing light for a gloomy global economy.  Since the announcement of the data points the dollar resumed its ascent and this will continue to erode not only emerging markets with debts tied to the dollar but exporters in the United States.  While this may not be a catalyst to cause a recession in the United States it may have the impact of taking the growth of the rest of the world lower.

I have to say that I am relatively surprised at the continued success of the United States economy and am hopeful that it can continue.  Certainly I do not see a deep drawn out recession on the horizon but I also do not see robust growth either.  I expect that the Federal Reserve will leave interest rates alone at the next meeting and unless there is a dramatic improvement in the global growth story or inflation in the United States starts to really take hold I doubt that there will be more than one more 1/4% increase in rates this year.

As far as the stock market goes then it may end up being a market full of gyrations and little upward or downward movement, sort of a barking dog situation.  This would not be a bad outcome when you consider such an extended bull market.  During this time it will be interesting to see how the Federal reserve acts and whether companies can somehow stem the slowdown in earnings however this will become harder and harder the higher the dollar climbs. For this reason I continue to expect weakness in the stock market but the damage may be limited to less than a bear market but that will be determined by the direction of the Federal Reserve as while the economy may be able to weather another rate hike I do not think the stock market has the backbone.

Friday, February 19, 2016

Range Bound

"Home, home on the range.  Where the deer and the antelope play.  Where seldom is heard a discouraging word and the skies are not cloudy all day." - A Scout Song

After the recent market draw down it appears that the market is now range bound and waiting for more stimulus from a central banker to break out higher or more poor economic data points to dive lower.  In the chart below I have drawn in blue lines showing the range.  As you can see from the chart there is real resistance against moving a lot higher and I would expect any upward move to be short lived and a selling opportunity.


The recent rally was created by the ECB when Mario Draghi hinted that further stimulus was on its way in the form of negative interest rates and more cash infusions.  This is all in an attempt to stave off deflation in Europe.  With the added stimulus the dollar continued on its path of strength and the 10-year yield fell to one of its lowest on record and is now around 1.7%.  While low this is still a big number compared to the rest of the developed world so I could see rates going lower from here.

In contrast to Europe in the United States the CPI (inflation) numbers for January were recently released and they are showing upward pricing pressure.  Total CPI was up 1.4% while core CPI was up 2.2% year over year.  This is far higher than the numbers expected particularly when you factor in a continued slide in the price of oil.  The two largest contributors were apparel and medical services but I have to say that outside of these two components I have been witnessing bumps in prices across the board from Starbucks to Rubios.  It will be interesting to see whether this upward trend is signalling an economic expansion or desperation of companies to maintain profits in the face of a weakening economy but what it will do is keep the Federal Reserve from lowering interest rates in the near term.

This means to me that the market will mark time and bounce around within its range until a clearer indication of the state of the global economy comes to light.  One thing that is not helping all of this confusion is that there is no clear indication of who will take over the White House.  I have to say that once again it looks like the candidates are less than optimal to deal with the economic crisis that they will face at home and abroad and this lack of leadership will not help the markets.  So for now sit tight and let everyone else fight over these meaningless gyrations in the market.

Friday, February 12, 2016

Hard Boiled?

When I was a student there was a ridiculous game that we used to play with eggs.  In a box of 6 eggs one was raw and the rest were hard boiled.  It was effectively a game of Russian roulette as you had to choose an egg and smash it on your head.  The loser was the unlucky person that selected the raw egg as it would break spattering egg all over them.  Typical students, anything to entertain ourselves rather than study!

The reason for my story is that the Federal Reserve has used five of their 6 eggs and all were hard boiled.  So we all know that the next step is to smash a raw egg on their heads and get it all over themselves.  Of course I am referring to Janet Yellen's testimony where she said that using negative interest rates to stimulate the economy was now not off the table.  Hold on a second, she is now talking about lowering rates to negative less than two months after the momentous increase in rates of 1/4%!  So it is looking as if the rate increase will not only be reversed but will be pushed into negative territory.  The United States will then be joining the rest of the developed world with negative rates.  Talk about egg on your face!

These negative rates are going to make earning any kind of a return on savings next to impossible.  Prudent savers and retirees will be hurt as the stimulus is targeting risk and higher returns at the expense of safety.  Furthermore I would expect that they will kick start the stimulus of pouring more money into a system already awash with money.  If this is not a recipe for inflation then nothing will be and the price of gold is starting to reflect this.  After years of languishing the metal has broken to the upside and seems to be on track to recoup its losses of the previous years.

Now while I expect inflation to show up it may not be for a while.  Oil continues to fall and with the poor earnings from Wall Street will come layoffs, taking the heat off the tightish labor market. That said personal inflation rates are far higher than the Federal Reserve numbers even with the benefit of lower gasoline prices.  In fact when you look at the price of gasoline while down to around $2.50 a gallon it is still significantly higher than the sub $1.00 a gallon that it was the last time oil was down at these levels.  Inflation is here and although not reflected in their numbers is causing problems for a consumer that has not received any form of a meaningful pay increase in a decade.  This will impact consumer spending so don't expect a resurgence in the economy even if they do try to "stimulate" again.  That said it may put a floor under an already overheated market but that is another story.

While I still do not expect much of a move from the Federal Reserve in the next month or so they are certainly not going to raise rates any time soon and if the market enters a formal bear market they will once again step into the fray and "save" the market.  Unfortunately their methods of saving are not helping but are in fact going to hurt even worse in the future so my advice is to take your chances on the gold front as that, in my mind, is the only place to turn.